Welcome to Belly Up Bar
At Belly Up Bar, nestled in the heart of Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, community and comfort reign supreme. Known for its inviting small-town atmosphere, patrons are greeted by friendly faces, both behind the bar and among fellow customers. The celebrated fish fry, particularly on Fridays, is a must-try, with the grilled cod and homemade warm German potato salad garnering rave reviews. Bartender Lori exemplifies exceptional service, ensuring every visit feels special. With a loyal following of regulars, this local gem promises not just a meal, but a warm sense of belonging—a perfect spot to unwind and indulge in hearty, memorable dishes.
Belly Up Bar: Reviews & Ratings
Small town feel. Friendly patrons, awesome bartenders and great owners. Grilled cod is amazing. Just a super place to unwind and enjoy.
Even though they are always very busy, their bartender, Lori gives us great service and is always friendly- from taking orders to always checking on her customers, she is the best. If Lori is not working, I usually turn around and go elsewhere.
I stopped by for the fish fry and homemade warm german potato salad,everything Was Great and people were friendly. I've returned to this establishment and will be going back soon.Yummy
Probably had one of the best fried fish which they only sell on Fridays! A blog recommended it and it definitely didn’t disappoint.
Superb fish fry. Especially the “grill top.” German potato salad also is delicious. Don’t expect anything but an establishment filled to the gills with “regulars,” but the staff are welcoming and provide prompt service, even to newcomers. Expect to wait, not many tables .
Belly Up certainly lived up to the fish fry hype! And had a absolutely delicious, house made, Bloody Mary.
We go here for the fish on Fridays. It is easily some of the best around.
This is a cute little dive bar I absolutely loved, good food, good prices, and awesome ladies working. One 1 bartender working in a full bar is very busy.
Location
-
N88W18384 Christman Rd, Menomonee Falls, WI 53051, United States Hotline: +1 262-255-2653
Welcome to Belly Up Bar, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin. Located at N88W18384 Christman Rd, this establishment encapsulates the essence of small-town charm blended with a lively atmosphere. With a phone number of +1 262-255-2653, they are eager to welcome patrons looking for a comfortable place to unwind.
Belly Up Bar stands out not just for its unique location, but for the strong sense of community it fosters. Regulars fill the seats alongside newcomers, all enjoying the warm greetings and friendly service that make this bar feel like home. As one customer, Curtis Yorkey, aptly put it, the bar has a "small town feel" and is perfect for unwinding after a long day.
- Notable Dishes: The grilled cod has earned rave reviews for its exceptional flavor, making it a must-try for seafood lovers. Patrons keep coming back for the lively Friday fish fry, where the fried fish is consistently described as some of the best around.
- Community Vibe: The bar is a hub of friendly patrons, with customers frequently praising the staff, particularly the bartender, Lori. Many return not just for the food but for the genuine care and attentiveness she provides during their visits.
- Specialties: The homemade warm German potato salad has received high marks, complementing the standout fish dishes beautifully. It's a comforting addition that enhances the overall dining experience.
Belly Up Bar is about more than just great food; it's about creating a space where friendships flourish and stories are exchanged over laughs. The welcoming staff and attentive service keep customers returning, and as Robert Berdan notes, expect to be enveloped by fellow regulars eager to share their experiences.
If you find yourself in Menomonee Falls, make sure to swing by Belly Up Bar. You're not just in for a meal; you’re stepping into a community-rich environment where every dish and every encounter leaves you feeling more connected.